M3 – Sono Kuroki Hagane Ep. 18: What hath science wrought?!

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1802

Lemme do a quick rank before we start. I just get the feeling that, like everything else about this show’s production, Okada just doesn’t give a damn. She’s phoning it in with M3. And I’m not saying she isn’t a hard worker. She’s obviously been very busy over the past few years. There’s no denying either that she’s written some respected stuff. But when you churn out this much material in such a short period of time, the magic slowly fades. There’s no love and care in M3. It just feels like a quick cash grab. When I look at all the ups and downs in Okada’s body of work, I wonder if she’s slowly turning into the Nic Cage of anime screenwriters. There’s no sense in saying that she’s working too much. After all, I know nothing about her life and her need to work on at least two or three shows every season. Nevertheless, it’s hard to see anything special in her work anymore. I haven’t fully enjoyed any of her series since Wandering Son and that was an adaptation.

— So the kids are headed for that island out in the boondocks? Why? So they can truly understand what happened back then. Oh yeah, those magical metal-immune trees can be found there too. The characters optimistically believe that a fruit from these trees might even revive Emiru. Can I just say, however, how nice it has been that Heito hasn’t said a single word since… since… well shit, I can’t even remember the last time I heard his dumb ass speak. Anyway, as much as I hate how Okada has emotionally tortured these characters, I’m not sure I like the idea of Emiru or even Sasame coming back to life. Chalk it up to Final Fantasy IV reviving all of its incapacitated characters, but I’ve always found it rather cheap when stories would just “kill” and “revive” their characters willy-nilly. You jerk my heart strings, make me come to terms with their “deaths,” only to go “Surprise, motherfucker!” Yeah, no thanks. If someone’s dead, just keep them dead. Even Jesus knew his resurrection was a mistake.

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1803

— Ugh, Mahmu’s boring-ass monologue about light and hope is so generic. I can’t believe a grown-up wrote this shit. Come on… come on… I know you read the script out loud to yourself during the review process. Are you seriously telling me you didn’t cringe when you re-read these lines: “Before the Lightless Realm was born, there was a small sliver of light. … This same sliver is said to shine within people’s hearts.”

— Apparently the only aircraft they can borrow incognito in the entire fucking country is located in… *drumroll* …the Lightless Realm. How very plot convenient.

— Kasane’s still trying to work with Natsuiri. I just want progress, man. After 18 episodes, I just want to see any slightest hint of progress. I’m not saying she should engage him in a fight to the death, but nothing’s changed. After all this time, he’s still a shady, unscrupulous asshole, and Kasane is still deferential to him. The best she could do was alter Akashi’s resonance data, thus allowing the guy to go unnoticed so he could sneak off to Yomijima. I guess I should just be happy she could even manage that much.

— Apparently, Natsuiri is very unhappy about everyone heading to Yomijima. He more than likely had a hand in its destruction.

— I don’t understand why Suzaki had to accompany the kids into the Lightless Realm. Are none of them capable of driving the vehicle? And if Suzaki is the most vulnerable to the effects of the Lightless Realm, then why the fuck would you put her behind the wheel?! I can’t help but wonder who’s going to pilot said carrier. Surely,  you’re not going to put the unstable woman in the cockpit, are you? Hey, I’m sure she’s quite capable under normal circumstances, but these are stupid, emo-metallizing circumstances.

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1804

— There’s just something funny about the characters whipping out assault rifles to defend themselves against the evil Lightless Realm creatures. Eat hot lead, you metal-based, uh, monsters…

— Oh man, Suzaki is going to pilot the carrier. But it’s okay, ’cause she’s “read the manual all last night.” And guys, I’m going to be fine as a school bus driver. I, too, read the manual all last night. Strap in, kids! Oops, I forgot school buses don’t have seat belts.

— No, no, really, it’s fine: “Manuals are written so that even novices can!” Why even bother training? These magical fucking manuals can do everything! Rather than studying, however, I think someone’s been hitting the bottle pretty hard, if you know what I mean. Glub, glub, glub. Sure, lady, you’re the best carrier pilot in the wooooorld.

— Seriously, how did they know the carrier was even in working condition? How did they know the carrier even had fuel? What if the fuel had turn to metal, huh? What then? There are even black blotches on the outside of the carrier to suggest that it isn’t impervious to the effects of the Lightless Realm. This whole mission just feels very poorly thought-out by the characters. What would’ve been their back-up plan had the carrier not worked? Or if Suzaki had succumbed to the effects of the Lightless Realm? Or if they had lost someone on the way there? How do they know there’s even a place to land anymore on Yomijima (it’s been years since anyone’s been there)? What if there isn’t a runway for the carrier to take off when they are finally ready to leave? There are so many questions that the anime doesn’t even bother to consider.

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1805

— Oh boy, Akashi is now blushing because his friends notice how he’s changed. He now worries about them! Awwwwww! It only took him 18 episodes to stop being an asshole! And all it took was a trip down memory lane with a yanderekko: “Oh shit, Tsumugi is crazy. I better shape up or they’ll leave me behind!”

— Now that they’ve returned to Yomijima, memories begin to flood back into Minashi’s mind. The anime makes it a point to highlight this woman in the guy’s flashback. I wonder who she is. His mom? A big sister?

— Walking into a former IX building triggers a painful memory in Minashi. Apparently, the villagers had been forced to undergo painful experiments at the hands of none other than Natsuiri, of course. The asshole’s horrific research eventually led the villagers to commit suicide.

— But sure enough, present-day Natsuiri has already tracked the kids all the way here. In fact, what on earth is this thing he’s brought with him? I can’t even begin to imagine what all those moving parts are supposed to accomplish.

— According to Natsuiri, it is the very first MA-Vess ever created. Seeing as how every single one of these mechas have required a LIM to operate. Oh boy, remember that woman we just saw in Minashi’s flashback? Lemme guess! It’s her, isn’t it!

— Yep, it’s his big sister. Guess we’re not quite done emotionally torturing these characters just yet.

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1806

— So apparently, the island was full of Linkers, people who could communicate with each other telepathically. Back when he was an idealistic young researcher, Natsuiri advanced the idea that everyone on the planet would eventually be able to develop telepathic abilities. Not only that, you could use this power to operate machines. In cliche anime fashion, however, none of his peers took Natsuiri nor his research very seriously. Y’know, in the real world, fellow researchers are usually very receptive to your ideas if you have the data to back it up, and it doesn’t look to me as if Natsuiri lacks data. So this scene feels rather forced and contrived. I mean, yes, history has seen many exceptions. Galileo suffered for his theories, but then again, he wasn’t addressing peers necessarily, but devout religious folks. I just find it hard to believe that a room full of curious learners would react to Natsuiri this way. But ah, we need everything to feel tragic, so we must contrive a situation in which nobody respected the guy. As a result, he went mad!

— So Natsuiri ends up befriending Maki, Minashi’s big sister. Even though she helped him gain some modicum of acknowledgement, however, he wanted more. He needed more than just Maki to experiment with. Reluctantly, she brought him back to the island she grew up on. There, the guy slowly went off the deep-end as he was willing to do whatever it takes to get the data he needed. The rest of the story is history. Nothing too original or compelling here.

— I mean, we’ve been waiting for this big revelation for months now, so now that it’s here, it’s just underwhelming. Blah blah, the horrors of science, mankind’s unchecked ambitions, divine punishment, etc. M3 is offering nothing new, but here’s the kicker: it was such a pain in the ass to get to this point.

M3 - Sono Kuroki Hagane 1807

— Natsuiri intends to turn the rest of the kids into Necrometal, but all of a sudden, restless spirits from the island begin to awaken! A Lightless Realm begins to appear on the island itself! Aaaand the episode comes to an end there.

— I can’t feel too bad for the villagers either. Yeah, it’s suck that their village got torched. It sucks that a lot of people in Natsuiri’s experiments ended up committing suicide. But one organization from the mainland doing you guys wrong? Let’s fuck the entire country over!

— Oh well, at least this show is almost over with. I’m still adamant in my belief that this should’ve just been a 1-cour series.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “M3 – Sono Kuroki Hagane Ep. 18: What hath science wrought?!

  1. flamerounin

    haven’t fully enjoyed any of her series since Wandering Son and that was an adaptation.

    I would suggest you try watching Nagi no Asukara. I liked it, though I wouldn’t vouch for it too much (considering me and you have different views). But, hey, Okada at least had a much more decent story going on for that one than this. Seriously, why can’t the woman have more consistency in her work?

    And I would just clear up what I said in your last Captain Earth post. CE definitely had a lot more potential going for it early on, with a few interesting storylines, But that show just can’t seem to put it’s act together into one story, which makes it disappointing. M3, on the other hand, now has one. Still, I find the story for this show just awfully horrid and boring.

    Now for this ep. I’ve said it several times, but shouldn’t we have at least seen bits of Natsuiri’s storyline some tens of episodes ago? And I just find it stupid how Okada doesn’t even give some valid reasoning behind Natsuiri’s experiments. You know, give some practical applications, so that we can go “Hey! the man might be crazy, but he is definitely on to something” Why would I even want to communicate without the need for words? For what purpose? After all that teasing, Natsuiri just goes from a mad scientist with no discernible motivation to, well, a mad scientist with no discernible motivation. It’s just exhaustingly stupid.

    Reply
    1. E Minor Post author

      But that show just can’t seem to put it’s act together into one story, which makes it disappointing. M3, on the other hand, now has one.

      At the end of the day, the only thing that matters to me is whether or not the show is enjoyable. Captain Earth is slightly more enjoyable to watch than M3.

      Reply
      1. flamerounin

        Yeah, that’s one thing i forgot to add about CE. It is incoherent, but I do find it’s silliness more bearable than this one.

        Reply
      2. akeem

        I left this episode feeling pretty blank. I mean why did he go crazy? It just isn’t convincing. Was changing the data the best kasane could do, did she even need to show up at the lab? Couldn’t she just have stayed home and that way she wouldn’t have been put in a situation where she felt that she needed to reveal the location of Akashi and Co. Was anyone ever trained to shoot a gun, I mean wasn’t it a Ma- Vess training camp or something.

        I find it hard to believe he killed his valuable test subjects like that, without any sort of feeling of regret or guilt. Being crazy is one thing but to actually kill people like that, people so vital to your research too it just feels so forced. I thought it was his mom too but of course it would be a big sister. What’s up with that?

        A question to E Minor too. From time to time you seem to express dislike for when characters are emotionally tortured. Is it that you don’t like when it happens at all or you just have a problem if it’s over done, or you think it’s bad writing to do that to make the audience feel sympathy for the characters. I’m sorry if the question isn’t too clear but whenever you mention it, it’s always in a negative light. Maybe it’s just being overdone in the animes that I read your posts on and you feel the need to mention it?

        Reply
        1. E Minor Post author

          A question to E Minor too. From time to time you seem to express dislike for when characters are emotionally tortured. Is it that you don’t like when it happens at all or you just have a problem if it’s over done, or you think it’s bad writing to do that to make the audience feel sympathy for the characters.

          There’s no balance here. It’s just cheap and lazy writing. Any writer can tug at our heartstrings by emotionally torturing his or her characters. When it happens once, I might let it slide. But when a story goes back to it over and over and over again, all this tells me is that the writer is aiming for the lowest hanging fruit.

        2. flamerounin

          But when a story goes back to it over and over and over again, all this tells me is that the writer is aiming for the lowest hanging fruit.

          And the sand part here is that there really doesn’t seem to be any point for the story to go back to it over and over again. For what purpose? Did the characters even learn and grow because of those experiences? From what I can see, absolutely not. It’s just for manufactured drama for the sake of manufactured drama.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s