Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji Ep. 12 (Finale): Another pretty boy from a broken family

Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji - 1204

That’s right. It’s the last episode. It’s also the episode where you get to learn about the bishie’s painful childhood. What a coincidence, huh? As you might have expected, Kyouya’s relationship with his mom is strained at best. His parents divorced when he was young, and this affected him badly. But gosh, a lot of bishies out there seem to come from broken families, don’t they? It’s like these shoujo stories suddenly feel the need to justify the love interest’s poor behavior or something. Guys, guys, I know he’s an asshole, but have some heart! He lost his mother when he was young! Sadly, I’m not even exaggerating. In Ao Haru Ride, Kou literally lost his mother to a terminal disease, and naturally, this broke the guy pretty badly until the heroine came along and kissed his emotional boo-boos away. Luckily for Kyouya, he’s a little better off; his mother is still alive. Still, I don’t know… I just think there’s something a little… sick about this. It’s like reverse moe, y’know?

One of the reasons why I started having a disdain for moe anime was because of the way it characterized its female characters. For instance, Mio of K-On!‘s fame is deathly afraid of barnacles. And here’s the kicker: it’s all for our amusement. Because she’s shaking with complete and utter fear, the target audience can’t help but look at her and coo, “Aw, Mio is so adorable!” But I think that’s disgusting. I think it’s fucked up to give a character a crippling fear just because it’s cute to you. Now, you’re probably thinking, “Mio isn’t a real person though, so what’s the big deal?” This sort of mentality seeps out in our daily lives, y’know. It just exhibits itself in less blatant ways. Like how a guy encourages his girlfriend to talk like a baby. Or how girls think they should act dumb to get attention. Or when girls shriek at the top of their lungs at the mere sight of a spider. These behaviors are encouraged because it makes their boyfriends feel manly by comparison. So you can’t always fall back on the excuse that anime is not real, and thus, anything goes.

Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji - 1215Creepy.

So what do I mean when I say that bishies exhibit reverse moe characteristics? Well, it seems to me that our good ol’ shoujo can’t just fall in love with a normal person, can she? She has to find that broken soul to nurture. She has to find that boy with the shattered family, so that she may step in and pick up the pieces. She needs that restoration project to fix up, because it’ll make her feel good about herself. Yeah, what an awesome girlfriend you are! And sure, we all have problems. And if both people in a relationship are perfect, little angels, that would make for a very boring story. But that’s the thing: only one person is ever broken in these cheap romances, and it’s always the bishie. It starts to feel disingenuous. Over and over again, we get to watch the Mary Sue swoop into these poor bishies’ lives and magically fix them up like some anime Mary Poppins. You don’t ever learn a goddamn thing about the heroines themselves, though. We know next to nothing about Erika’s parents or her life at home.

Technically, Erika isn’t perfect. Technically, she a huge fucking liar. Not only that, she is terribly insecure, and she feels that she has to show off to her friends in order to feel fulfilled. But that’s the oppositional reading. That’s not what the story wants you think whatsoever. After all, Erika continues to be friends with those shallow classmates of hers. After all, she continues to be the Wolf Girl from start to finish. We got all these episodes about Kyouya and Kyouya’s bad behavior, but did we get a single episode to address Erika’s need to tell lies all the time? Nope, never. In fact, she even uses her Wolf Girl powers for “good” in this last episode. She lies to Kyouya’s mother to convince the woman to come see the fireworks with them. So in the end, lying can be a good thing! Our heroine is perfect after all! Yaaaaay! The fact of the matter is, Erika’s character hasn’t developed whatsoever. These shoujo heroines are either complete or utter Mary Sues from the start, or you’re just going to have to accept the whole package, flaws and all. On the other hand, the bishie becomes a reclamation project.

Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji - 1209
Worship the Mary Sue for her love and compassion!

It’s just disingenuous, that’s all. A romance should be a story between two people. Instead, I feel like I’m watching a charity case. A very self-serving charity case, mind you. We’re not looking at these bishies as fully realized characters. They’re just a concept. They’re a concept to fill a gap in the Mary Sue’s life, because society tells her that her life is empty without a boyfriend. So we watch as the heroine initially suffers. Oh, how selflessly she suffers! But it’s okay! It’ll all be worth it in the end when she mends the bishie’s tortured soul, and they proceed to have their storybook romance afterwards… which occurs offscreen, of course. ‘Cause hey, nobody needs to see that. Nobody needs to see two loving individuals care about each other. I’d much rather watch the Mary Sues of the world pump themselves up because they’re willing to brave treacherous waters in order to save our troubled pretty boys. Naturally, if you nevertheless come from broken family, but you do not have supermodel good looks, you need not apply.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji Ep. 12 (Finale): Another pretty boy from a broken family

  1. Paulo27

    Harems do the exact same thing, there’s the perfect male and then a bunch of broken girls he goes to fix, I guess girls don’t really like having that many guys around them so one is enough for shoujo romance, while males want all the girls they can get.

    Reply
  2. Akeem

    Excellent post Mr. E Minor. I think we do underestimate the effect that media has on us, I mean if multiple studies agree that music can influence us, then why not movies/ TV shows that are even more immersive? The examples you use are spot on too. I remember this girl a grade lower than me who was acting just like a Moe character. She talked like a baby, she behaved clumsy and she went as far to bring a stuffed animal much like the loli in inou battle. The guys liked her of course, she was really popular but I just found it sad that she was doing all that to get attention.
    I also have a female friend who claims to like bad boys, boys she can fix and change. Like you said I’m sure fixing someone makes her feel good about her self and I go that from her explanation too. When we have shows like this one playing inspiring music and crap when the girl suffers through all this garbage and have the guy magically change it paints a this messed up picture.
    I’ve seen it happen plenty of times, some friend of mine goes for a guy who they know aren’t relationship material and they end up being the one on the losing side.

    I’ve been enjoying these post so much that I tried watching this episode but I couldn’t make It past the opening. I like the song I think it sounds great but I felt pretty sad for Erika by the end of it.

    Reply
  3. mintrubber

    Divorce doesn’t make someone a charity case… that’s a little (very) insulting. I don’t think you realize just how common divorced families are.

    They needed to explain why he acts like such a huge stand-offish asshole. It wouldn’t have made any sense for him to have had a perfect home life and life in general, this is probably the most ‘trivial’ and common trauma you can give your character.

    The meta-reason for him being an asshole is that it makes the story more interesting. There are shoujo with happy, perfectly nice guys (Kimi ni todoke comes to mind), but those are /boring/ to watch for 13 episodes. Romances need a little mystery.

    Reply
    1. E Minor Post author

      Divorce doesn’t make someone a charity case… that’s a little (very) insulting. I don’t think you realize just how common divorced families are.

      I meant he’s being helped not because he’s a child of a divorced family and that we care what he goes through, but because it makes the shoujo feel better. After all, we only find out about the extent of his problems at the last possible second. So obviously, his story is not the focus. Just the shoujo’s good feels. But if you want to be offended and interpret my words in the worst possible light, I don’t really care. Not going to waste my time with it, though.

      Reply
    2. Anonymous

      In KImi ni Todoke I’d argue it’s the girl that’s the charity case for the guy, but it kind of backfires on him. The series does drag on more than it should but I feel it always gives a good reason why Sawako isn’t ready for a relationship yet; it’s a very good show in that regard. She also turns out to be a wonderful and unique individual regardless of her awkwardness so she doesn’t necessarily need his help. Plus, the fact that our point of view is centred on the – let’s call her – abnormal character avoids the pitfalls E minor is talking about and gives the show more humanity.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s