Let’s Reflect on 2009

One more old man and it'd be a lemon party.

I was trying to come up with an idea of what to blog about, but the latest Letter Bee was a filler episode and I couldn’t be assed to watch another Miracle Train. In the end, I decided to take a look back at 2009. This post doesn’t necessarily reflect the views of Moe Sucks as a whole nor is it meant to be comprehensive. If I didn’t mention a particular anime, it’s only because it wasn’t the best, surprising nor disappointing. I didn’t want to talk about the bad either because, well, I think most anime are just plain bad (I’ll never understand why people think this is an odd position for an anime fan; most movie fans would agree that most movies suck) and the rest of the blog already covers a part of that.

Let’s go backwards.


The Best

I’ve written so much on Aoi Bungaku already, so there’s really nothing left for me to say. Although I wish Madhouse could have been more faithful to their adaptations, I gotta say they did an amazing job.

The Surprisingly Decent

I can’t really think of any series in the current season that made me go, “Wow, I certainly didn’t expect that to be so good.” Nyan Koi! might have been it, but the last third of the season took such a nosedive.

The Disappointingly Bad

Trapeze is painfully boring to me. At some point, the wacky animation became visual noise and I plain stopped paying attention to it. As for the stories themselves? They felt like they came straight out of a Psychology 101 textbook, which would have been tolerable with strong characters driving the action, but there are none. It eventually just slipped from my viewing schedule and I watch Miracle Train sometimes. That says a lot.


The Best

Eh… I think this was the worst season of 2009 by far. I guess Kuruneko was cute. To tell the truth, this blog went on hiatus for quite a few weeks during the summer because I simply could not get interested in any of the anime in the summer. In hindsight, I was just a tad wrong because…

The Surprisingly Decent

…I actually enjoy Umineko no Naku Koro ni. Out of curiosity, I began watching it again a few weeks ago, and it’s somehow entertaining. This really is an anime that is greater than the sum of its parts. I think the art direction is ghastly and the story is ridiculously silly, but that’s the best part. There’s just something very pulpy about this series. The last few episodes have been boring (GET OFF THE SCREEN ANGE), however, so I can’t really say this is a great anime. Have you guys heard of The Room by Tommy Wiseau? It’s this really stupid movie that has developed a cult following among moviegoers. Umineko isn’t THAT bad, but it’s the same kind of experience for me: grab some popcorn and just see dueling witches. Nyoron and I never miss the OP just for the screencap above.

The Disappointingly Bad

For me, Bakemonogatari became a show more about character types rather than characters themselves. I could not buy into either Senjougahara or Araragi so I eventually stopped watching halfway into the series. I think Shaft can do strong characterizations and I think ef (I only saw the first season however) is some evidence of that, but when I look at either Senjougahara or Araragi, I don’t see two individuals. Instead, I see just another typical tsundere chick and another typical harem lead. The only difference from other shows is that they’ve been “Shaft-ed.” Just by being a Shaft anime alone, I’m afraid, isn’t enough. The visual gimmicks do nothing for me this time around — and they have always been gimmicks, but at least in other Shaft shows, the humor carried the day. A lot of people might say Bakemonogatari is a dark comedy, but I just didn’t laugh. I didn’t cry. I didn’t care.

Just let him go.

On an additional note, throw in Zan Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei. When SZS first rolled around, it was fresh and interesting. Two more seasons and it’s the same format, the same structure, the same style. I still like the first season, but no more please.

Wasn’t Haruhi S2 also disappointing? For me, not really; before the first episode  of S2 came out, I had tried to rewatch the first season and it just didn’t hold up anymore. I dropped the second season after two episodes, right before the “Endless Eight” fiasco.

Death by Bones.

Finally, Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 might have gone here, but I never expected it to be good or anything. In fact, I find Bones rather mediocre for all the hype they get.


The Best

I’ve said my piece on Eden of the East here.

The Surprisingly Decent

Like in the Fall season, I can’t think of anything that surprised me.

The Disappointingly Bad

Enough vitriol has been written about K-On! on the web and I’m not gonna beat the dead horse again. All I can say is that I did have high hopes for it, but the realization that it was just another anime full of moe settled in around the Christmas episode.


The Best

I just think Shaft is in their element when they do comedy and Maria+Holic is no different. I think it’s a great parody and it deserves to stay that way. A lot of people wonder if Kanako would ever get with either Mariya or one of the many girls she fawns over. I think any sequel would unfortunately have to go down that path, and that would be a shame. The show works best, in my opinion, as a jab against all those people who must endlessly pair characters together.

The Surprisingly Decent

I haven’t finished it, but I wonder why I never gave Rideback a chance when it first came out. I’m only starting to watch it now and it looks like a solid anime so far. I don’t watch everything Madhouse puts out (e.g. Kobato), but they’re usually a good bet.

The Disappointingly Bad

Can’t really think of any.


16 Replies to “Let’s Reflect on 2009”

    1. I personally think the first arc is the weakest, but I’m probably in the minority. I bet it resonated more with anime viewers than the other three adaptations. For me, “Run, Melos” was the most enjoyable.

  1. Haven’t seen all the series you discussed, but I agree about Aoi Bungaku, Eden of the East, and Umineko. I would say Haruhi S2 was not so much “disappointing” as “outrageous” or “shocking.” I like Bakemonogatari (and I don’t have a particular affinity for Shaft at all) but I agree that it’s overrated.

  2. Surprising that most of the fall season stuff didn’t make it into your cut. But hey, it was one of the worst (if it wasn’t for the Kara no Kyokai movies) seasons aside from Winter (which was saved by, again, Kara no Kyokai) IMO.

    BTW, it’s sad that Saki wasn’t even mentioned for the sake of yuridom.

    1. Make the cut for what? Outside of a couple anime, I thought the fall season would suck and then it did suck.

      And LOL, you’re at the wrong blog if you think anyone here would like Saki.

      1. Well if it counts I’m reading the manga out of nostalgia for exaggerated shounen titles that take something completely enjoyable yet mundane, add in lots of special effects and special moves and call it an anime (Beyblades, Crush Gear). And I can thank this blog for interesting it to me after reading the post about how exaggerated it really was.

        But then again, I think you can tell by now I’m certainly one of the more lenient person following this blog.

        And before you ask, no I’m not watching Bakugan.

        1. But then again, I think you can tell by now I’m certainly one of the more lenient person following this blog.

          I don’t even know what there is to be lenient about. Everyone’s got opinions and we’ve got ours.

  3. So I’m not the only one who believes that “moe” sucks more than it should.

    Me? I’d usually throw in the trash any animu that features a male lead who’s a complete wuss (for the sake of its wuss audience).

    So what are your feelings about these titles? Chrome-shelled Regios, 07-Ghost, Valkyria Chronicles, Black Butler, Tactics, Zombie Loan, Busou Renkin, E’s Otherwise, and Gundam Wing.

    1. I played Valkyria Chronicles, the game, way before I ever saw the anime. I didn’t like how they turned the Alicia into a tsundere. The potential “love triangle” (even though everyone on the planet knew she would end up with Welkin) was also a bit silly. I dropped it about 10 episodes in, I think. It’s one of those shows where I felt the anime added nothing worthwhile, and since the game is fun, why not just play the game instead?

      I saw only an episode of Zombie Loan and I can barely remember it right now so can’t comment.

      There’s like a billion Gundam Wing iterations, but if you mean the most recent one, I haven’t seen it. After a span of marathoning a few (like Eureka Seven and Macross), I don’t really care for mecha shows anymore.

      I haven’t seen Black Butler.

      07 Ghost seemed yaoi-y, which doesn’t really matter if it’s interesting. I tried to give it at least three episodes, but it was very boring after two, so I stopped watching.

      Didn’t see Chrome-Shelled Regios. People said it was decent, but I bet that just means pretty girls getting violent.

      1. Well I didn’t play the Valkyria Chronicles game. But I’m glad that the anime didn’t feature as many spineless young guys as the lot of other animu out there. Why FUNimation didn’t pick this up when they should… …well… Let’s hope they don’t mind Viz taking their crown.

        As for Regios: It’s mainly about this kick-arse male lead trying to live a normal life at some high-end academy until everyone forced him back into being kick-arse. And then there’s these gigantic bugs that needed to be eliminated. So about the “pretty girls getting violent,” that’s the reason.

        Finally, 07-Ghost is not as yaoi-ish as people have you believe. Okay; it’s boring, but it picks up after a while.

          1. Well… I don’t wanna tell you what you don’t wanna do, but you should atleast give it a try. Yes, there’s there’s this deadpan DFC loli-esque chick called Felli. But it’s a good show with cool character once you get past her.

            And. Regios != Chaos Head.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.